SARFAESI Act, 2002

Objective

  • SARFAESI Act empower banks and financial institutions to recover their non-performing assets (NPAs) efficiently.
  • Allows them to enforce the security interest without judicial intervention.
  • Examples: SBI auction sarfaesi​ , BoB auction sarfaesi​, etc

Key Features

  1. Scope:
    • Applies to secured loans where security is charged to the bank (e.g., hypothecation, mortgage).
    • Not applicable to unsecured loans or agricultural land.
  2. Powers under SARFAESI:
    • Securitization: Converting loans into tradable securities.
    • Asset Reconstruction: Acquiring NPAs and restructuring them for recovery.
    • Enforcement of Security Interest: Taking possession of assets and selling them to recover dues.
  3. Eligibility for Action:
    • Account must be classified as NPA under RBI norms.
    • Outstanding loan amount should be More than Rs. 1 Lakh (or as per the Act’s latest guidelines).
    • Dues must be Greater than 20% of the principal loan and interest.

Process of Recovery under SARFAESI Act

  1. Demand Notice:
    • Bank issues a 60-day demand notice to the borrower to repay dues.
  2. Borrower’s Rights:
    • Borrower can respond to the notice or raise objections within the notice period.
  3. Possession of Assets:
    • If dues are not settled, the bank takes possession of the secured assets.
  4. Auction or Sale:
    • Bank auctions or sells the assets to recover dues after proper public notice.

Key Entities under SARFAESI

  1. ARC (Asset Reconstruction Companies):
    • Specialized institutions to acquire and manage NPAs from banks.
    • Regulated by RBI.
  2. Central Registry of Securitisation Asset Reconstruction and Security Interest (CERSAI):
    • Established to prevent multiple loans against the same property.
    • Maintains a registry of all security interests created by banks.

Advantages of SARFAESI

  • Speeds up the recovery process without going through courts.
  • Reduces NPAs, improving financial stability of banks.
  • Provides legal tools for asset reconstruction.

Limitations of SARFAESI

  • Not applicable for unsecured loans or smaller loan amounts.
  • Borrowers may challenge the process in Debt Recovery Tribunals (DRT), causing delays.
  • Requires strict adherence to procedural norms, else actions may be declared invalid.

1. National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT)

Purpose:

  • Handles matters related to company law and corporate insolvency resolution under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), 2016.

Key Functions:

  • Deals with insolvency cases for companies and limited liability partnerships (LLPs).
  • Facilitates restructuring, mergers, and amalgamations.
  • Resolves disputes between shareholders and companies.

Process in NCLT:

  • A company or creditor files an application for insolvency resolution.
  • NCLT appoints an Interim Resolution Professional (IRP).
  • The IRP works with creditors to resolve the issue, or the company goes into liquidation.

Advantages:

  • Faster resolution of disputes compared to traditional courts.
  • Focused approach to insolvency and company-related issues.

2. Debt Recovery Tribunal (DRT)

Purpose:

  • Special tribunal to recover debts owed to banks and financial institutions by individuals or entities.

Jurisdiction:

  • Handles cases where the debt exceeds Rs. 20 Lakhs.
  • Works under the Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy Act (RDBA), 1993.

Key Features:

  • Focuses on recovery of secured and unsecured loans.
  • Does not allow counterclaims unless directly related to the recovery.
  • Provides quicker recovery mechanisms for financial institutions.

Process in DRT:

  • Bank or financial institution files an application for recovery.
  • Tribunal hears the case and issues recovery certificates.
  • The recovery officer enforces the tribunal’s order to recover dues.

Advantages:

  • Streamlined process compared to civil suits for debt recovery.
  • Less expensive and time-consuming for banks and financial institutions.

3. Civil Suit

Purpose:

  • Legal proceedings initiated in a civil court to resolve disputes between individuals, companies, or organizations.

Scope:

  • Covers a wide range of disputes, including contracts, property, family matters, and recoveries not falling under specialized laws like SARFAESI or IBC.

Key Features:

  • Can be filed for both small and large claims.
  • Allows counterclaims and broader remedies like compensation or injunctions.
  • Time-consuming due to procedural formalities.

Process in a Civil Suit:

  • Plaintiff files a suit in a competent civil court.
  • Defendant is notified and given an opportunity to respond.
  • Case proceeds with evidence and hearings.
  • Judgment is passed, which can be appealed if necessary.

Disadvantages:

  • Comparatively slower than NCLT or DRT.
  • High litigation costs over time.

Comparison Table

AspectNCLTDRTCivil Suit
PurposeCorporate insolvency & company disputesDebt recovery by banks/financial institutionsResolving general civil disputes
Applicable LawIBC, 2016; Companies Act, 2013RDBA, 1993; SARFAESI Act, 2002Civil Procedure Code, 1908
JurisdictionCompanies and LLPsSecured/Unsecured debts > Rs. 20 LakhsIndividuals/entities for various issues
Time TakenFaster (within 330 days for IBC cases)Faster compared to civil courtsSlower due to procedural delays
CounterclaimsLimitedNot allowed (unless related to recovery)Allowed
SpecializationCorporate and insolvency issuesDebt recovery casesGeneral civil matters

When to Use

  • NCLT: For insolvency resolution or corporate disputes involving companies/LLPs.
  • DRT: For recovering large debts owed to banks or financial institutions.
  • Civil Suit: For broader disputes not covered under specialized laws like IBC or SARFAESI.

Important Provisions of SARFAESI Act, 2002

1. Section 2 – Definitions

  • Non-Performing Asset (NPA): An account classified as per RBI guidelines.
  • Asset Reconstruction Company (ARC): Companies set up to acquire bad loans.
  • Secured Creditor: Any bank or financial institution holding a security interest.

2. Section 13 – Enforcement of Security Interest

  • Allows secured creditors to enforce their security without court intervention if the borrower defaults.
  • Steps:
    1. Notice Period: A 60-day notice to the borrower demanding repayment.
    2. Taking Possession: If the borrower fails to repay, the creditor can seize the secured asset.
    3. Asset Disposal: Secured assets can be sold to recover dues.

3. Sec 14 of sarfaesi Act​ – Chief Metropolitan Magistrate (CMM) Assistance

  • If the borrower obstructs the possession of secured assets, the secured creditor can seek the help of the CMM or District Magistrate (DM) for enforcement.

4. Section 15 – Takeover of Management

  • Secured creditors can take over the management of a borrower company to recover dues.

5. Section 17 – Right to Appeal (DRT)

  • Borrowers can file an appeal against the creditor’s action before the Debt Recovery Tribunal (DRT).
  • Appeal Time: Within 45 days from the date of possession or notice.

6. Section 18 – Appeal to DRAT

  • If unsatisfied with the DRT’s decision, the borrower or creditor can appeal to the DRAT.
  • Condition: Borrowers must deposit 50% of the dues before appealing.

7. Section 20 – Central Registry (CERSAI)

  • Establishes CERSAI (Central Registry of Securitisation Asset Reconstruction and Security Interest of India) to maintain records of:
    • Security interests.
    • Secured creditors’ claims.

8. Section 34 – Bar on Civil Courts’ Jurisdiction

  • Civil courts are barred from entertaining cases related to the enforcement of security interests under SARFAESI. Only DRT or DRAT has jurisdiction.

9. Section 36 – Limitation Period

  • Secured creditors can initiate action only within 12 years from the date of default or cause of action.

Other Noteworthy Points

  1. Threshold for Action: Loans below ₹1 lakh or cases where the total outstanding amount is less than 20% of the principal cannot be enforced under SARFAESI.
  2. Exceptions: Agricultural land cannot be seized under this Act.
  3. Amendments (2016):
  • Empowered NBFCs to act as secured creditors.
  • Cooperative banks brought under the Act’s purview.

Structure for Easy Memorization

  • Notice Period: Section 13.
  • CMM Assistance: Section 14.
  • Appeals: Sections 17 (DRT) & 18 (DRAT).
  • Bar on Civil Courts: Section 34.
  • Central Registry (CERSAI): Section 20.

MCQ

1. What is the primary purpose of NCLT?
a) Resolving criminal disputes in companies
b) Handling insolvency and company disputes
c) Recovering debts for banks
d) Managing mergers in public sector banks

Answer: b) Handling insolvency and company disputes

2. Under which act was NCLT established?
a) Companies Act, 2013
b) SARFAESI Act, 2002
c) Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016
d) RDBA, 1993

Answer: a) Companies Act, 2013

3. Who appoints the Interim Resolution Professional (IRP) under NCLT proceedings?
a) Ministry of Finance
b) Reserve Bank of India
c) NCLT
d) High Court

Answer: c) NCLT

4. Which of the following cases can NCLT handle?
a) Recovery of small personal loans
b) Insolvency of companies and LLPs
c) Disputes involving agricultural loans
d) Criminal cases related to companies

Answer: b) Insolvency of companies and LLPs


5. What is the minimum loan amount required to initiate action under SARFAESI?
a) Rs. 50,000
b) Rs. 1 Lakh
c) Rs. 5 Lakhs
d) Rs. 10 Lakhs

Answer: b) Rs. 1 Lakh

6. What is the time period given to borrowers to respond to a demand notice under SARFAESI?
a) 30 days
b) 45 days
c) 60 days
d) 90 days

Answer: c) 60 days

7. Which type of property is exempt under SARFAESI?
a) Residential property
b) Agricultural land
c) Commercial property
d) Industrial equipment

Answer: b) Agricultural land

8. What is the role of CERSAI in SARFAESI?
a) Auctioning secured assets
b) Filing cases against defaulters
c) Registering security interests created by banks
d) Managing the repayment schedules of borrowers

Answer: c) Registering security interests created by banks


9. What is the minimum debt amount required for a case to be filed in DRT?
a) Rs. 5 Lakhs
b) Rs. 10 Lakhs
c) Rs. 15 Lakhs
d) Rs. 20 Lakhs

Answer: d) Rs. 20 Lakhs

10. DRT primarily deals with cases related to:
a) Consumer disputes
b) Corporate insolvency
c) Debt recovery by banks
d) Labor laws

Answer: c) Debt recovery by banks

11. Who can file a case in DRT?
a) Borrowers against banks
b) Banks and financial institutions
c) Government agencies
d) Private individuals

Answer: b) Banks and financial institutions

12. Appeals against DRT decisions are made to which authority?
a) Civil Court
b) Supreme Court
c) Debt Recovery Appellate Tribunal (DRAT)
d) High Court

Answer: c) Debt Recovery Appellate Tribunal (DRAT)

13. In which court are civil suits filed?
a) Criminal Court
b) Civil Court of competent jurisdiction
c) NCLT
d) DRT

Answer: b) Civil Court of competent jurisdiction

14. Which type of disputes can be resolved through civil suits?
a) Property disputes
b) Insolvency cases
c) Debt recovery for banks
d) Company law disputes

Answer: a) Property disputes

15. What is the primary drawback of civil suits?
a) High litigation costs and delays
b) Limited jurisdiction
c) Lack of legal representation
d) No provision for appeals

Answer: a) High litigation costs and delays

16. Which tribunal is specialized for recovering bank loans under SARFAESI?
a) DRT
b) NCLT
c) Civil Court
d) High Court

Answer: a) DRT

17. Which act governs the resolution of insolvency for companies in India?
a) RDBA, 1993
b) SARFAESI Act, 2002
c) Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016
d) Companies Act, 2013

Answer: c) Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016

18. Under SARFAESI, if a borrower disagrees with the proceedings, they can appeal to:
a) Civil Court
b) DRT
c) DRAT
d) High Court

Answer: b) DRT

19. What is the key distinction between DRT and civil suits?
a) DRT handles criminal cases; civil suits do not.
b) DRT focuses on debt recovery for banks; civil suits cover broader disputes.
c) Civil suits are faster than DRT proceedings.
d) DRT cannot issue recovery certificates.

Answer: b) DRT focuses on debt recovery for banks; civil suits cover broader disputes.

20. NCLT handles insolvency cases for:
a) Individuals only
b) Companies and LLPs only
c) Individuals and companies
d) Government agencies

Answer: b) Companies and LLPs only